|
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
The objective of this review is to provide an approach to the diagnosis and management of PCAP for pulmonary physicians. This review is limited to previously healthy, postneonatal, immunocompetent children. SignificancePCAP accounts for 37% of the community-acquired pneumonia cases, or 1.5 million cases, in the United States each year.7 The incidence peaks between 1 and 5 years of age, and declines in older children. PCAP remains a major cause of pediatric morbidity and health-care costs, accounting for numerous emergency room visits, office visits, and hospitalizations. In 1996, 178,000 hospital admissions with an average length of stay of 3.6 days8 were attributed to PCAP. It is the most frequent diagnosis of patients admitted to the pediatric ICUs, where the average cost per stay is estimated to be $12,342.9 Only 1,000 deaths from PCAP occurred in 1995.8 Mortality in the United States tends to be associated with S pneumoniae bacteremia and sepsis, but in developing countries, mortality is associated with malnutrition and poor access to medical care. EtiologyThere is a spectrum of pathogens that commonly cause PCAP, including both bacterial and viral agents. The exact incidence of each agent is unknown because an exact etiology is only rarely determined. The most commonly reported bacterial pathogens include S pneumoniae, Moraxella catarrhalis, Haemophilus influenzae (usually nontypable if the patient has received the H influenzae serotype B vaccine), Mycoplasma pneumoniae, and Chlamydia pneumoniae.10 In addition, numerous respiratory viruses are reported to cause PCAP, with respiratory syncytial virus (RSV), influenza A and B, and adenovirus accounting for the majority. Two recent studies attempted to determine the incidence of each pathogen as a cause for PCAP (Fig 1). An etiology was identified in only half of the cases and often was based on serologic testing. Together, these studies indicated that S pneumoniae was the most common pathogen across all age groups, and that while the incidence of viral pathogens decreased among older children, the incidence of M pneumoniae and C pneumoniae increases with age.5,10
DiagnosisAlthough adolescents may demonstrate the classic adult presentation of pneumonia, including the abrupt onset of symptoms, high fever, productive cough, pleuritic chest pain, and possible toxic appearance, the presentation of the younger child with PCAP is often subtle. It may include any combination of fever, lethargy, tachypnea, irritability, vomiting, diarrhea, and poor feeding. Physical findings are variable based on age, size of the child, easy transmission of breath sounds, absence of crackles, and skill of the examiner.11 Studies evaluating the use of physical exam findings to diagnose PCAP have shown that such findings are limited. No one finding can be used to diagnose or exclude pneumonia, but the absence of all the findings of tachypnea, crackles, fever, and decreased breath sounds excludes the diagnosis of PCAP with 100% specificity. The findings most sensitive for predicting infiltrate on the chest radiograph were tachypnea, cough, and toxic appearance. Grunting, flaring, and pallor were the most specific predictors for pulmonary infiltrate (Table 2).12-14 Because the clinical presentation of PCAP may be subtle, radiographic and laboratory studies aid in the diagnosis of PCAP and allow identification of its etiology. Chest RadiographsA chest radiograph is generally regarded as the gold standard for confirming the presence of PCAP. The routine use of a screening chest radiograph for every child with a cough or fever is not appropriate. In one study of 121 febrile children without respiratory symptoms, chest radiography failed to identify a single case of PCAP.15 In another study, however, 18% of children with S pneumoniae pneumonia had no respiratory symptoms.16 In children younger than 3 years old in whom abnormal clinical signs and symptoms are absent, a chest radiograph identified pneumonia in up to 25% of patients with a fever > 39.6°C and a WBC count > 15,000 cells/mm3.17,18 A chest radiograph should be obtained in toxic-appearing children without an identifiable source of infection, children younger than 36 months of age with fever > 39.6°C and WBC > 15,000 cells/mm3, and children with the classical presentation of PCAP. Infiltrate patterns are not sensitive to determine the etiology of PCAP. S pneumoniae is as likely to cause alveolar infiltrates as interstitial infiltrates. While there is some modest predictive value of alveolar infiltrates for bacterial pneumonia, both bacterial and viral etiologies must be considered in the presence of either type of infiltrate. Several studies have confirmed these findings.19-21 When a child's clinical course is deteriorating or failing to improve, an additional radiograph may be helpful to identify complications. These may include pleural effusion, lung abscess, or the presence of an obstructing foreign body.16 In uncomplicated pneumonia, a follow-up chest radiograph is unlikely to alter management. CT of the ChestChildren with PCAP who respond poorly to treatment rarely require CT of the chest to direct management. CT scans may reveal abnormalities in complicated pneumonia that are not obvious by a chest radiograph. These may include parenchymal and pleural complications and pericardial effusions. CT should be considered in this very select population.22 Laboratory StudiesWBC count cannot differentiate viral from bacterial pneumonia. In a study of 121 patients with PCAP, no statistically significant differences in leukocyte count among children with viral, bacterial, or mixed pneumonias were noted. Additionally, C-reactive protein and erythrocyte sedimentation rates have been studied, and the results are similar to those for leukocyte count. These studies suggest they are of little value in determining an etiology of the PCAP.23-25 Antigen tests for Influenza A and B and RSV are readily available. Their sensitivity for detection is > 70% with a specificity approaching 100%.26-28 Although some clinicians commonly collect blood cultures when PCAP is suspected, the necessity of doing so is controversial. In the outpatient setting, blood cultures dramatically increase the expense of treatment without greatly influencing management decisions. Antibiotic decisions in outpatients and the need for re-evaluation of therapy are primarily based on clinical judgment.18 In inpatients, the incidence of bacteremia associated with pneumonia is higher in children than adults.29 In hospitalized patients, blood cultures may help direct the antibiotic coverage and even narrow it if an organism is isolated. The sensitivity for detecting bacteremia increases with increasing number of sets collected, approaching 99% with three sets.29 The risk of bacteremia with PCAP is greatest among the very young and increases with fever and high leukocyte counts.18 Pulse OximetryThe presence of hypoxemia associated with PCAP is an indication for admission. In children, the sensitivity of physicians detecting hypoxemia clinically is less than 40%. Accordingly, it is appropriate to use pulse oximetry in the routine assessment of PCAP.30 Inpatient vs Outpatient TreatmentCriteria for the admission of children with PCAP are similar to those for adults. In addition to considering severity of illness, ability to maintain hydration and take oral medication, and opportunity for follow-up, the physician must also consider the family support structure and seek to identify the primary caregiver. Children, especially young children, are often dependent on their caregivers to administer the medication. If the ability or motivation of the caregiver(s) to administer the medication is in doubt, admission should be considered (Table 3).29 TreatmentThe treatment of PCAP is almost always empirical, as it is extremely rare that a causative organism is identified before antibiotics are selected (Table 4). Because it is difficult to distinguish between bacterial, viral, and mixed infections, most children with PCAP are treated with antibiotics. When selecting empirical therapy, it is important to consider the spectrum of likely pathogens and risk for resistant organisms. Goals of timely therapy include expediting clinical improvement and preventing complications.31 S pneumoniae is the most common bacterial cause of PCAP in all ages.32 Elevated minimum inhibitory concentrations (MICs) to penicillin are being identified in S pneumoniae (0.1 to 1.0 mg/mL, intermediate; 1.0 to 2.0 mg/mL, resistant) and are increasingly more common among children younger than 6 years and those attending day-care centers. Fortunately, at this time, S pneumoniae isolates with an MIC > 4.0 mg/mL are rare. Current studies suggest that in the absence of meningitis, beta-lactam antibiotics are effective treatment against S pneumoniae with MIC to penicillin < 4.0 mg/mL.33,34 The newer macrolides continue to be effective against a broad range of pulmonary pathogens, including most S pneumoniae. Azithromycin offers improved activity over clarithromycin against H influenzae.35 Vancomycin should be reserved for very ill patients in whom there is a suspicion of methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus or S pneumoniae with an MIC to penicillin > 4.0 mg/mL.36 Fluoroquinolones, widely used to treat community-acquired pneumonia in adults, are not approved for use in children. Tetracycline may be used in children whose permanent front teeth have erupted, usually around age 8 years. Linezolid has not been approved for pediatric use. Antibiotic SelectionOutpatient. Empiric therapy for PCAP in children aged 3 months to 5 years is predominately directed at S pneumoniae (Table 4). Amoxicillin with or without clavulanate is usually the drug of choice in otherwise healthy children. In penicillin-allergic patients, a macrolide can be used. Erythromycin is the only one approved for children younger than 6 months. After age 5 years, empirical therapy should include coverage for M pneumoniae and C pneumoniae, necessitating the use of a macrolide. Newer macrolides are preferred over erythromycin because of increased activity against S pneumoniae.37 Empirical therapy for PCAP in hospitalized patients aged 3 to 6 months may include ceftriaxone or cefotaxime. These specific third-generation cephalosporins cover the pathogens likely to cause PCAP, and will treat meningeal infection that may be subtle in this age group. Ceftriaxone, cefotaxime, or cefuroxime are appropriate in the 6 months to 5 years age group. In children older than 5 years, a macrolide may be added for coverage of atypical bacterial pathogens. In critically ill children, vancomycin may be considered as additive therapy to ceftriaxone or cefotaxime. Again, it is prudent to treat children in this group with antibiotics that also treat meningeal infection, as the clinician may be unable to adequately assess the presence of meningitis in a critically ill child.4 The administration of an initial parenteral dose (IV or IM) of antibiotic to outpatients with PCAP who are moderately ill is common practice.38,39 Reasons offered to justify this practice include timely initiation of therapy and a desire to attain high tissue concentrations rapidly. Additionally, concerns over the patient's compliance and tolerance of oral medications are addressed. Reports regarding empirical outpatient ceftriaxone therapy are usually in the context of preventing complications.40 Evidential support for outpatient empirical parenteral cephalosporin therapy for pneumonia is limited. A recent retrospective review of children with S pneumoniae bacteremia treated as outpatients supports it. Children who were initially administered a parenteral antibiotic were more likely to have an improved condition at a follow-up visit. They were also less likely to require subsequent hospitalization. Notably, children treated with oral agents alone also did well.41 Siegel et al42 conducted a study in adult inpatients with community-acquired pneumonia who received ceftriaxone initially, followed by oral antibiotics. This group did equally as well as the group who received a longer course of parenteral antibiotics. Empirical parenteral outpatient therapy in PCAP likely has an important role, but it remains to be defined. Response to TherapyChildren treated for PCAP as outpatients should be reassessed 24 to 48 h after the initial visit. If the child's condition has deteriorated further, the clinician should consider inpatient treatment of the child. Within 48 to 72 h of appropriate treatment initiation, a clinical response should be noted in children with bacterial PCAP. The clinical response time in atypical pneumonias is less clear, and in cases of viral pneumonias, 7 to 10 days may be needed for acute symptoms to resolve. In any case, if some improvement is not noted within 72 h, repeat laboratory studies and chest radiograph should be obtained and therapy re-examined.43,44 When treating inpatients for PCAP, a switch from IV to oral antibiotics is appropriate when the fever has abated and the patient can tolerate oral medication and is otherwise clinically improving. Patients may be discharged when the criteria for outpatient management of PCAP are met.36 Patients with bacterial PCAP occasionally develop complications, either acutely or subacutely. These complications are most commonly associated with S pneumoniae in children younger than 2 years and include meningitis, purpura fulminans, arthritis, parapneumonic effusions, empyema, abscess formation, endocarditis, and pericarditis. Mortality, although rare, is usually related to the development of meningitis. There is no increased risk of morbidity or mortality associated with the presence of penicillin-resistant S pneumoniae.45 Complications of viral PCAP, including focal necrosis and airway plugging, may lead to atelectasis, bronchospasm, apnea spells, and respiratory failure. Rarely, ARDS occurs. Long-term sequelae of viral pneumonia include recurrent reactive airway disease, bronchiectasis, bronchiolitis obliterans, and rarely pulmonary fibrosis.29 Irreversible reduced lung function has been noted to occur in adults with histories of PCAP.46,47 Special ConcernsAntiviral agents have been used in the treatment of PCAP, but their role is controversial. The efficacy of ribavirin for RSV has been variable in clinical trials. Its use is considered in hospitalized patients who are at risk for or already have developed severe disease from RSV infection. Several antiviral agents have activity against influenza A, and one against influenza B. It is unclear whether or not they prevent complications or can treat influenza pneumonia. Aspirin should be avoided because of the increased risk of Reye's syndrome in children with influenza infections. If concurrent otitis media is present and amoxicillin is used, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention recommend high-dose amoxicillin in children at risk for drug-resistant S pneumoniae infections. When concurrent bacterial meningitis is suspected, vancomycin and ceftriaxone or cefotaxime should be used until sensitivities are obtained and coverage can be narrowed. SummaryAlthough the diagnosis of pneumonia in adults is recognized based on history and examination findings, in children, signs and symptoms of PCAP may be subtle. Tachypnea, cough, and toxic appearance are relatively sensitive but not specific for the diagnosis. Grunting, flaring, pallor, retractions, and crackles are fairly specific but not sensitive. When combined with fever > 39°C, both the sensitivity and specificity of these signs and symptoms increase. Pulse oximetry should be obtained in all patients in whom pneumonia is suspected. A chest radiograph should be obtained if (1) the diagnosis is questionable; (2) this is a repeated episode; (3) the patient is ill enough to be admitted; (4) the child is younger than 3 years and has a fever > 39°C without a source and leukocytosis > 15,000 mm3; or (5) a complicated pneumonia is suspected. Blood culture may be reserved for inpatients as it is unlikely to alter the outpatient management in a pediatric setting. During RSV and influenza seasons, it may be useful to check antigen tests for these viruses; however, it must be remembered that mixed bacterial and viral infections are not uncommon. Children who are very young, hypoxic, toxic-appearing, lethargic, hyperirritable, or in respiratory distress should be admitted and empirical treatment should be initiated as soon as possible. For outpatient treatment of PCAP, a newer macrolide or amoxicillin with clavulanate may be used for patients younger than 5 years, and a macrolide for older children. Children who are ill enough to be admitted should be treated with parenteral therapy. Older infants and children should be treated with a second- or third-generation cephalosporin (ceftriaxone or cefotaxime). In children 5 years and older, a macrolide may be added. When an inpatient with PCAP improves enough to meet criteria for outpatient therapy, the treatment may be changed to comparable oral antibiotics. Total therapy should continue for 7 to 10 days in an uncomplicated pneumonia. S aureus pneumonia and complicated pneumonias may require more extensive intervention and length of therapy. Finally, an initial IM injection of ceftriaxone has limited evidential support but is a widely accepted and utilized practice. References
Copyright ©2001 American College of Chest Physicians |
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||